Flutter or Airtera: which OPEP device?

Both do the same job

Both the Flutter and the Airtera are oscillating positive expiratory pressure devices. You blow into them, the airflow oscillates, the vibration loosens mucus, and a gentle cough clears it.

Neither uses medication or power. Both are included on the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods as a mechanical positive pressure airway secretion-clearing device.

The differences are practical rather than theoretical, and they decide which one suits a particular person.

Side by side

Flutter Airtera OPEP
How it oscillates Steel ball in a cone Mechanical pressure oscillation
Position it must be held in Held correctly, gravity dependent Any orientation
Patient can sit, stand, recline or lie down Sitting upright Yes
Resistance Fixed Adjustable
Can a nebuliser be attached No Yes
See it working No Transparent shell
Weight 85 g Compact, with storage rack
ARTG 389978, Flexicare Australia 464507, Wymedical

Why orientation is the real difference

With a ball-in-cone device, gravity is part of the mechanism. The ball has to lift and fall in a cone held at the right angle. Tip it, or lie back with it, and the oscillation is no longer what the design intended.

For a healthy adult sitting at a table, that is a non-issue. For the people who actually need mucus clearance it often is one:

  • Someone breathless finds sitting upright and holding a position harder, not easier
  • Someone being treated in bed, or recovering after surgery, may not be able to sit up at all
  • A child will not reliably hold anything at a fixed angle
  • Someone frail or with limited grip cannot keep a device steady for a 10 minute session

The Airtera's design is documented as working in multiple orientations, with the patient free to sit, stand, recline or lie down. That is not a marketing nicety. It is the difference between a therapy being done properly and being done approximately.

Adjustable resistance

The Flutter has one resistance. The Airtera has a resistance indicator and adjustable settings.

That matters in two directions. Someone with weak expiratory effort may not be able to drive a fixed resistance well enough to get good oscillation. Someone stronger may want more. And a person's capacity changes, during a recovery or across a bad week, where a fixed device cannot follow.

Using a nebuliser at the same time

The Airtera is designed to take a nebuliser attached inline, so medication can be delivered during the session rather than as a separate treatment.

Where someone is already nebulising and already doing mucus clearance, combining the two saves a treatment slot in the day. That matters more than it sounds to anyone doing both several times daily.

Which to choose

Situation Device
Adult, able to sit upright, straightforward daily use Flutter
Treated in bed, recovering, or cannot sit upright Airtera
Breathless, frail, or limited grip Airtera
Child Airtera
Expiratory effort varies, or is weak Airtera, for the adjustable resistance
Already using a nebuliser at the same time Airtera
Wants the long established original design Flutter

Before you choose either

Both should be used on the advice of a doctor or physiotherapist, who will also tell you how often and for how long.

There are situations where an OPEP device is not appropriate at all. The Flutter instructions list acute right-sided heart failure, pneumothorax, severe tuberculosis and coughing up blood. Read the instructions supplied with whichever device you have.

Frequently asked questions

Is one more effective than the other? They work on the same principle. The practical differences are position, resistance and whether a nebuliser can be attached.

Can I share a device? No. These are single patient devices.

Can I use it lying down? With the Airtera, yes, it is designed for use in multiple orientations. A ball-in-cone device needs to be held correctly.

How long do they last? Follow the instructions supplied. Replace if damaged, or if the device no longer oscillates as it should.

This article is general information, not medical advice. Use these devices on the advice of a doctor or physiotherapist, and follow the instructions supplied.

Products in this article